Homeowners claim paid rates by group

57% of reported homeowners claims across 180 groups closed with a payment

Group

Companies

Paid rate

Closed paid

Closed unpaid

Reported

▶ NAIC 17227

164%

14,270

2,227

8,679

▶ CORE SPECIALTY INS HOLDINGS GRP

100%

2,476

2,480

▶ NAIC 14656

97%

1,651

1,708

▶ WESTERN NATIONAL MUTUAL

95%

14,823

721

15,544

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
WESTERN NATL MUT INS CO	15377	95%	14,122	687	14,809
PIONEER SPECIALTY INS CO	40312	95%	164	8	172
UMIALIK INS CO	40126	95%	164	8	172
WESTERN NATIONAL ASSUR CO	24465	95%	164	8	172
NEVADA GEN INS CO	10007	96%	111	5	116
AMERICAN FREEDOM INS CO	10864	95%	98	5	103

▶ NAIC 19194

87%

2,391

358

2,749

▶ TRAVELERS

87%

857,417

53,179

986,314

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
ST PAUL FIRE & MARINE INS CO	24767	87%	260,359	16,113	299,228
TRAVELERS CAS & SURETY CO	19038	87%	213,826	13,245	245,762
TRAVELERS IND CO	25658	87%	176,130	11,096	203,402
STANDARD FIRE INS CO	19070	87%	42,192	2,507	48,402
UNITED STATES FIDELITY & GUAR CO	25887	87%	38,660	2,462	44,590
TRAVELERS CAS INS CO OF AMER	19046	87%	23,797	1,411	27,279
TRAVELERS IND CO OF CT	25682	87%	14,380	876	16,494
FARMINGTON CAS CO	41483	87%	12,974	817	14,944
NORTHLAND INS CO	24015	87%	12,802	782	14,685
PHOENIX INS CO	25623	86%	10,278	699	11,890
ST PAUL PROTECTIVE INS CO	19224	87%	5,072	315	5,835
CHARTER OAK FIRE INS CO	25615	87%	5,006	308	5,739
TRAVELERS COMMERCIAL INS CO	36137	87%	4,933	293	5,643
TRAVELERS CAS CO OF CT	36170	87%	4,116	254	4,730
TRAVELERS COMMERCIAL CAS CO	40282	87%	4,116	254	4,730
TRAVELERS PROP CAS CO OF AMER	25674	88%	3,777	222	4,316
ST PAUL MERCURY INS CO	24791	87%	3,504	215	4,023
TRAVELERS PROP CAS INS CO	36161	88%	3,149	184	3,595
AUTOMOBILE INS CO OF HARTFORD CT	19062	87%	2,814	187	3,247
THE TRAVELERS CAS CO	41769	87%	2,538	153	2,908
TRAVELERS CONSTITUTION STATE INS CO	41750	87%	2,538	153	2,908
TRAVELERS LLOYDS OF TX INS CO	41564	89%	2,155	127	2,410
TRAVELERS IND CO OF AMER	25666	87%	1,583	107	1,829
NORTHLAND CAS CO	24031	87%	1,214	73	1,395
TRAVCO PERSONAL INS CO	36463	87%	1,214	73	1,395
FIDELITY & GUAR INS UNDERWRITERS INC	25879	88%	865	50	988
ST PAUL GUARDIAN INS CO	24775	88%	865	50	988
TRAVCO INS CO	28188	87%	554	35	637
TRAVELERS HOME & MARINE INS CO	27998	87%	554	35	637
TRAVELERS PERSONAL INS CO	38130	87%	554	35	637
TRAVELERS PERSONAL SECURITY INS CO	36145	87%	554	35	637
FIRST FLORIDIAN AUTO & HOME INS CO	10647	84%	344	13	411

▶ NAIC 11003

86%

911

1,055

▶ NAIC 10202

86%

1,124

1,311

▶ NAIC 13072

86%

2,707

204

3,158

▶ NAIC 22624

85%

5,085

912

5,997

▶ ARBELLA

83%

2,316

487

2,803

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
ARBELLA MUT INS CO	17000	83%	1,760	370	2,130
ARBELLA PROTECTION INS CO	41360	83%	371	78	449
COVENANT INS CO	10062	83%	116	24	140
ARBELLA IND INS CO	10017	82%	69	15	84

▶ NAIC 17320

83%

2,941

364

3,560

▶ ALFA

82%

22,040

547

26,783

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
ALFA MUT INS CO	19135	82%	9,257	230	11,249
ALFA MUT FIRE INS CO	19143	82%	8,375	208	10,177
ALFA MUT GEN INS CO	19151	82%	1,322	33	1,607
ALFA GEN	41661	82%	882	22	1,072
TREXIS	12188	82%	882	22	1,072
ALFA	22330	82%	661	16	803
TREXIS ONE	11004	82%	661	16	803

▶ NAIC 10688

82%

1,171

257

1,428

▶ NAIC 14834

81%

4,315

995

5,310

▶ TIPTREE FINANCIAL

81%

1,530

370

1,900

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
FORTEGRA SPECIALTY INS CO	16823	79%	925	249	1,174
RESPONSE IND CO OF CA	10970	83%	605	121	726

▶ NAIC 10182

79%

4,247

354

5,343

▶ NAIC 10887

79%

12,145

1,018

15,305

▶ GeoVera Insurance Company

79%

9,413

786

11,864

▶ PENNSYLVANIA NATIONAL

79%

4,745

1,256

6,001

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
PENN NATL SECURITY INS CO	32441	79%	2,256	604	2,860
PENNSYLVANIA NATL MUT CAS INS CO	14990	79%	2,256	604	2,860
FOUNDERS INS COMPANY	10994	86%	141	23	164
PARTNERS MUT INS CO	13439	79%	92	25	117

▶ NATIONWIDE

79%

573,390

96,284

726,855

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
NATIONWIDE MUT INS CO	23787	79%	535,017	89,860	678,145
NATIONWIDE AGRIBUSINESS INS CO	28223	79%	19,872	3,280	25,161
NATIONAL CAS CO	11991	79%	6,625	1,092	8,387
NATIONWIDE INS CO OF AMER	25453	79%	6,625	1,092	8,387
NATIONWIDE GEN INS CO	23760	78%	5,164	904	6,598
SCOTTSDALE IND CO	15580	49%	83	54	170
SCOTTSDALE SURPLUS LINES INS CO	10672	57%	4	2	7

▶ NAIC 27065

79%

1,035

281

1,316

▶ DONEGAL

79%

19,254

3,062

24,492

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
ATLANTIC STATES INS CO	22586	79%	10,665	1,716	13,563
DONEGAL MUT INS CO	13692	79%	5,678	862	7,162
SOUTHERN INS CO OF VA	26867	77%	1,414	228	1,835
MICHIGAN INS CO	10857	78%	743	141	947
PENINSULA INS CO	14958	73%	502	88	683
SOUTHERN MUT INS CO	15172	83%	252	27	302

▶ NAIC 12810

78%

1,265

208

1,612

▶ NAIC 23779

78%

54,051

8,562

69,076

▶ NAIC 10117

78%

3,588

122

4,628

▶ NAIC 16799

76%

1,495

348

1,955

▶ NAIC 11932

76%

1,661

513

2,174

▶ NAIC 16713

76%

1,055

238

1,383

▶ CHUBB

76%

205,031

16,223

269,377

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
ACE AMER INS CO	22667	76%	45,991	3,658	60,636
FEDERAL INS CO	20281	76%	45,991	3,658	60,636
ACE PROP & CAS INS CO	20699	76%	36,793	2,925	48,507
PACIFIC IND CO	20346	76%	36,793	2,925	48,507
EXECUTIVE RISK IND INC	35181	76%	18,396	1,463	24,254
VIGILANT INS CO	20397	79%	12,368	880	15,614
CHUBB IND INS CO	12777	79%	6,657	439	8,462
CHUBB LLOYDS INS CO OF TX	27774	81%	1,931	113	2,397
CENTURY IND CO	20710	0%	0	146	146
CHUBB CUSTOM INS CO	38989	76%	110	16	145
AGRI GEN INS CO	42757	0%	0	0	72
ILLINOIS UNION INS CO	27960	100%	1	0	1

▶ NAIC 20320

76%

2,048

493

2,698

▶ NAIC 13889

75%

7,500

2,436

9,936

▶ NAIC 20176

75%

1,340

370

1,777

▶ NAIC 20184

75%

1,265

349

1,678

▶ Miami Mutual Insurance Company

75%

1,116

309

1,481

▶ NAIC 20430

75%

1,351

1,794

▶ KENTUCKY FARM BUREAU

75%

48,673

9,133

65,050

▶ NAIC 14044

75%

4,501

1,106

6,039

▶ Wawanesa General Insurance Company

74%

11,595

3,993

15,588

▶ SELECTIVE

74%

12,872

3,862

17,451

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
SELECTIVE INS CO OF AMER	12572	73%	9,277	2,855	12,658
SELECTIVE WAY INS CO	26301	75%	1,110	311	1,480
SELECTIVE INS CO OF SC	19259	75%	476	133	634
SELECTIVE CAS INS CO	14376	75%	370	104	494
SELECTIVE INS CO OF NY	13730	75%	370	104	494
SELECTIVE INS CO OF THE SOUTHEAST	39926	75%	370	104	494
SELECTIVE AUTO INS CO OF NJ	11074	75%	317	89	423
MESA UNDERWRITERS SPECIALTY INS CO	36838	75%	264	74	352
SELECTIVE FIRE & CAS INS CO	14377	75%	159	44	211
SELECTIVE INS CO OF NEW ENGLAND	11867	75%	159	44	211

▶ AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP

74%

5,003

309

6,792

▶ National Security Fire & Casualty Company

73%

5,403

1,330

7,432

▶ WESTFIELD

73%

34,341

9,596

47,311

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
WESTFIELD NATL INS CO	24120	70%	13,193	4,186	18,934
WESTFIELD INS CO	24112	75%	13,126	3,358	17,613
OHIO FARMERS INS CO	24104	75%	4,619	1,181	6,197
OLD GUARD INS CO	17558	75%	2,188	560	2,936
AMERICAN SELECT INS CO	19992	74%	1,215	311	1,631

▶ Teachers Insurance Company

72%

3,257

1,280

4,537

▶ NAIC 26859

72%

12,362

4,564

17,288

▶ Horace Mann Insurance Company

71%

23,902

9,706

33,608

▶ Horace Mann Property & Casualty Insurance Company

71%

15,390

6,251

21,641

▶ NAIC 41475

71%

2,407

684

3,385

▶ Pacific Specialty Insurance Company

71%

26,030

5,565

36,761

▶ FRANKENMUTH GRP

71%

12,746

4,178

18,035

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
FRANKENMUTH INS CO	13986	71%	11,914	3,914	16,865
ANSUR AMER	10984	71%	416	132	585
PATRIOT INS CO	32069	71%	416	132	585

▶ NAIC 16889

70%

2,034

860

2,894

▶ NAIC 34592

70%

1,678

717

2,395

▶ Diamond State Insurance Company

70%

816

306

1,169

▶ MS & AD

70%

7,663

868

11,017

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
TRANSVERSE INS CO	21075	71%	6,554	176	9,184
MITSUI SUMITOMO INS CO OF AMER	20362	61%	846	545	1,391
DTRIC INS CO LTD	37265	59%	121	51	204
MITSUI SUMITOMO INS USA INC	22551	59%	92	63	155
MSIG SPECIALTY INS USA INC	34886	60%	50	33	83

▶ Motors Insurance Corporation

69%

26,021

5,592

37,568

▶ CENTRAL MUT INS CO GRP

69%

23,018

8,266

33,368

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
CENTRAL MUT INS CO	20230	69%	19,336	6,942	28,028
ALL AMER INS CO	20222	69%	3,682	1,324	5,340

▶ NAIC 26735

69%

780

123

1,133

▶ THE HANOVER

69%

233,354

86,600

340,036

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
HANOVER INS CO	22292	68%	91,164	34,607	134,396
CITIZENS INS CO OF AMER	31534	69%	89,045	33,522	129,696
MASSACHUSETTS BAY INS CO	22306	67%	28,849	11,159	42,907
CITIZENS INS CO OF THE MIDWEST	10395	72%	17,978	5,670	24,834
CITIZENS INS CO OF IL	10714	79%	3,735	887	4,743
HANOVER AMER INS CO	36064	75%	2,324	675	3,111
CITIZENS INS CO OF OH	10176	74%	259	80	349

▶ STATE FARM

69%

4,236,325

1,909,435

6,174,242

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
STATE FARM FIRE & CAS CO	25143	70%	3,930,019	1,711,149	5,641,168
STATE FARM GEN INS CO	25151	64%	224,121	127,080	351,201
MGA INS CO INC	40150	46%	68,052	50,699	147,233
STATE FARM FL INS CO	10739	41%	13,865	20,137	34,002
DOVER BAY SPECIALTY INS CO	15894	42%	268	370	638

▶ NAIC 34525

68%

790

366

1,156

▶ Universal North America Insurance Company

68%

20,585

3,839

30,235

▶ BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY

68%

61,447

11,907

90,566

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
NATIONAL IND CO	20087	68%	23,737	4,570	35,037
NORGUARD INS CO	31470	68%	16,981	3,203	24,906
AMGUARD INS CO	42390	68%	13,207	2,493	19,371
EASTGUARD INS CO	14702	68%	4,729	889	6,943
WESTGUARD INS CO	11981	78%	1,299	175	1,659
NATIONAL FIRE & MARINE INS CO	20079	52%	782	367	1,507
AZGUARD INS CO	16495	75%	582	92	774
UNITED STATES LIAB INS CO	25895	39%	67	57	172
RSUI IND CO	22314	17%	14	24	83
US UNDERWRITERS INS CO	35416	33%	21	21	63
MOUNT VERNON FIRE INS CO	26522	53%	26	16	49
COLUMBIA INS CO	27812	100%	2	0	2

▶ TRISURA

67%

25,290

3,113

37,504

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
TRISURA INS CO	22225	65%	20,955	3,059	32,126
TRISURA SPECIALTY INS CO	16188	81%	4,335	54	5,378

▶ NAIC 14257

67%

3,062

1,005

4,573

▶ NAIC 14761

67%

3,658

1,152

5,476

▶ NAIC 13684

66%

1,948

597

2,930

▶ American Reliable Insurance Company

66%

2,353

1,038

3,541

▶ NAIC 16330

66%

1,710

132

2,576

▶ MICHIGAN FARM BUREAU

66%

21,053

7,207

31,744

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
FARM BUREAU GEN INS CO OF MI	21547	66%	12,932	4,539	19,605
FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO OF MI	21555	67%	8,121	2,668	12,139

▶ RLI

66%

1,964

1,001

2,965

▶ ACUITY A MUT INS CO

66%

7,250

2,347

11,001

▶ NORTH CAROLINA FARM BUREAU

66%

86,381

29,775

131,104

▶ Pharmacists Mutual Insurance Company

66%

1,574

431

2,393

▶ WEST BEND INS CO

66%

47,862

15,790

72,852

▶ AMTRUST FINANCIAL SERV GRP

66%

2,729

542

4,160

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
TECHNOLOGY INS CO INC	42376	66%	1,508	301	2,289
WESCO INS CO	25011	65%	657	132	1,006
DEVELOPERS SURETY & IND CO	12718	65%	257	53	396
SECURITY NATL INS COMPANY	19879	64%	225	45	354
SOUTHERN INS CO	19216	71%	82	11	115

▶ American Summit Insurance Company

66%

6,480

3,226

9,878

▶ NAIC 15715

65%

4,725

7,219

▶ AIG

65%

295,953

89,816

452,189

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
NATIONAL UNION FIRE INS CO OF PITTSB	19445	66%	139,628	41,993	213,019
AMERICAN HOME ASSUR CO	19380	66%	130,048	38,925	198,237
LEXINGTON INS CO	19437	64%	18,320	6,446	28,739
COMMERCE & INDUSTRY INS CO	19410	65%	7,884	2,443	12,087
STRATFORD INS CO	40436	68%	73	9	107

▶ Virginia Farm Bureau Mutual Insurance Company

65%

5,104

2,062

7,838

▶ ERIE

65%

94,499

18,913

145,679

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
ERIE INS EXCH	26271	65%	88,008	17,667	136,006
ERIE INS CO	26263	65%	4,657	935	7,197
ERIE INS PROP & CAS CO	26830	78%	1,368	218	1,757
ERIE INS CO OF NY	16233	65%	466	93	719

▶ AU HOLDING CO

65%

4,683

2,311

7,253

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
CALIFORNIA INS CO	38865	68%	2,656	1,259	3,915
CENTAURI SPECIALTY INS CO	12573	49%	657	414	1,330
CONTINENTAL IND CO	28258	68%	570	269	839
CENTAURI NATL INS CO	16181	69%	345	154	499
PENNSYLVANIA INS CO	21962	68%	190	91	281
ILLINOIS INS CO	35246	68%	186	89	275
TEXAS INS CO	16543	89%	54	7	61
CONSTITUTION INS CO	32190	47%	25	28	53

▶ NAIC 12944

64%

19,645

10,946

30,591

▶ NAIC 18686

64%

1,485

544

2,330

▶ NAIC 13854

63%

1,174

332

1,868

▶ BROOKFIELD REINS LTD GRP

63%

60,617

26,598

96,487

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
AMERICAN NATIONAL PROP & CAS CO	28401	63%	57,577	24,859	91,236
AMERICAN NATL GEN INS CO	39942	57%	2,652	1,584	4,622
ARGONAUT INS CO	19801	62%	388	155	629

▶ NAIC 15091

63%

2,119

722

3,384

▶ NAIC 14850

62%

8,908

1,810

14,375

▶ CLEAR BLUE FINANCIAL GRP

62%

25,879

9,762

41,973

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
CLEAR BLUE INS CO	28860	60%	19,854	7,986	33,000
CLEAR BLUE SPECIALTY INS CO	37745	66%	3,255	1,003	4,903
ROCK RIDGE INS CO	11089	68%	2,770	773	4,070

▶ CSAA

62%

177,372

78,009

287,898

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
CSAA INS EXCH	15539	61%	123,189	55,696	202,588
CSAA GEN INS CO	37770	63%	49,308	20,280	77,690
CSAA FIRE & CAS INS CO	10921	64%	3,491	1,505	5,458
CSAA AFFINITY INS CO	11681	64%	1,384	528	2,162

▶ First American Property & Casualty Insurance Company

62%

2,444

1,524

3,968

▶ Quincy Mutual Fire Insurance Company

61%

1,021

313

1,664

▶ NAIC 13125

61%

1,208

766

1,974

▶ FAIRFAX FINANCIAL

61%

1,016

232

1,662

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
UNITED STATES FIRE INS CO	21113	61%	780	179	1,276
NORTH RIVER INS CO	21105	61%	225	51	369
CRUM & FORSTER IND CO	31348	65%	11	2	17

▶ Topa Insurance Company

61%

5,370

2,314

8,785

▶ ALLIANZ

61%

858

158

1,406

▶ Stillwater Insurance Company

61%

52,077

24,143

85,354

▶ UNITED FIRE & CAS

61%

989

414

1,623

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
UNITED FIRE & CAS CO	13021	71%	578	177	814
FINANCIAL PACIFIC INS CO	31453	50%	402	235	797
UFG SPECIALTY INS CO	19526	75%	9	2	12

▶ NAIC 12247

61%

1,827

787

3,003

▶ ENCOVA MUTUAL

60%

3,286

1,392

5,437

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
MOTORISTS COMMERCIAL MUT INS CO	13331	56%	1,280	672	2,267
BRICKSTREET MUT INS CO	12372	63%	1,118	400	1,764
MOTORISTS MUT INS CO	14621	63%	559	200	882
CONSUMERS INS USA INC	10204	63%	44	16	70
IOWA MUT INS CO	14338	63%	44	16	70
MICO INS CO	40932	63%	39	14	62
PINNACLEPOINT INS CO	15137	63%	39	14	62
SUMMITPOINT INS CO	15136	63%	39	14	62
ALLEGHENYPOINT INS CO	13016	63%	32	12	51
PHENIX MUT FIRE INS CO	23175	63%	32	12	51
NORTHSTONE INS CO	13045	63%	30	11	48
WILSON MUT INS CO	19950	63%	30	11	48

▶ UNIVERSAL INS HOLDING GRP

60%

37,858

25,308

63,166

▶ TOKIO MARINE HOLDINGS INC

60%

22,747

13,339

38,013

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
PRIVILEGE UNDERWRITERS RECP EXCH	12873	62%	19,716	11,842	31,558
FIRST INS CO OF HI LTD	41742	38%	1,623	1,030	4,318
TOKIO MARINE AMER INS CO	10945	66%	1,001	327	1,507
PHILADELPHIA IND INS CO	18058	71%	333	51	467
PURE SPECIALTY EXCHANGE	17148	45%	74	89	163

▶ PLYMOUTH ROCK

59%

2,745

1,335

4,640

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
BUNKER HILL INS CAS CO	13643	59%	549	267	928
BUNKER HILL INS CO	16037	59%	549	267	928
BUNKER HILL PREFERRED INS CO	16035	59%	549	267	928
BUNKER HILL PROP INS CO	16036	59%	549	267	928
PLYMOUTH ROCK HOME ASSUR	10394	59%	549	267	928

▶ MERCURY GEN

59%

106,279

57,314

180,305

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
CALIFORNIA AUTOMOBILE INS CO	38342	58%	56,992	29,727	98,827
MERCURY CAS CO	11908	61%	24,374	12,869	39,975
AMERICAN MERCURY INS CO	16810	60%	14,021	8,364	23,519
AMERICAN MERCURY LLOYDS INS CO	25470	59%	8,183	5,118	13,799
MERCURY INS CO OF GA	34410	66%	2,032	885	3,085
MERCURY INS CO OF IL	34444	62%	677	351	1,100

▶ NAIC 12482

59%

1,841

940

3,127

▶ NAIC 15210

59%

897

463

1,524

▶ WR BERKLEY

59%

3,505

1,170

5,956

▶ Ocean Harbor Casualty Insurance Company

59%

8,406

2,799

14,301

▶ NAIC 27022

59%

1,237

522

2,108

▶ CSE Safeguard Insurance Company

59%

595

320

1,014

▶ AMICA MUTUAL

58%

109,918

47,214

189,469

▶ AUTO CLUB ENTERPRISES

58%

261,644

154,919

451,123

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
INTERINS EXCH OF THE AUTOMOBILE CLUB	15598	58%	259,721	153,705	447,766
AUTOMOBILE CLUB INTERINS EXCH	15512	57%	1,923	1,214	3,357

▶ AUTO OWNERS

58%

11,012

4,934

19,013

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
CALIFORNIA CAPITAL INS CO	13544	56%	5,523	2,824	9,805
CONCORD GEN MUT INS CO	20672	62%	2,523	739	4,053
EAGLE W INS CO	12890	56%	1,448	738	2,569
MONTEREY INS CO	23540	56%	996	509	1,768
GREEN MOUNTAIN INS CO INC	20680	63%	242	61	382
STATE MUT INS CO	16020	63%	160	33	255
SUNAPEE MUT FIRE INS CO	28479	71%	77	17	109
VERMONT ACCIDENT INS CO INC	13110	60%	43	13	72

▶ California Casualty Indemnity Exchange

58%

19,464

9,364

33,626

▶ PROGRESSIVE

58%

169,203

100,594

292,617

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
AMERICAN STRATEGIC	10872	56%	119,016	76,308	211,900
PROGRESSIVE CAS INS CO	24260	61%	14,844	7,879	24,162
ASI LLOYDS	11059	65%	10,535	4,412	16,316
ASI SELECT	14042	57%	7,593	4,526	13,352
ASI PREFERRED	13142	66%	4,474	1,391	6,778
PROGRESSIVE NORTHWESTERN INS CO	42919	60%	2,864	1,587	4,767
UNITED FINANCIAL CAS CO	11770	65%	2,941	1,325	4,525
ASI HOME	11072	65%	2,426	970	3,704
PROGRESSIVE SPECIALTY INS CO	32786	60%	1,671	927	2,781
PROGRESSIVE NORTHERN INS CO	38628	66%	684	300	1,036
ARTISAN & TRUCKERS CAS CO	10194	69%	664	271	966
PROGRESSIVE PREFERRED INS CO	37834	66%	342	150	518
ASI ASSUR	12196	65%	310	130	480
PROGRESSIVE MI INS CO	10187	66%	228	100	345
PROGRESSIVE CLASSIC INS CO	42994	66%	171	75	259
PROGRESSIVE AMER INS CO	24252	66%	114	50	173
PROGRESSIVE GULF INS CO	42412	66%	114	50	173
PROGRESSIVE MOUNTAIN INS CO	35190	66%	57	25	86
PROGRESSIVE SOUTHEASTERN INS CO	38784	66%	57	25	86
PROGRESSIVE HI	10067	40%	27	30	68
PROGRESSIVE BAYSIDE INS CO	17350	65%	28	13	43
PROGRESSIVE FREEDOM INS CO	12302	65%	28	13	43
PROGRESSIVE SECURITY INS CO	10050	31%	12	24	39
DRIVE NJ INS CO	11410	18%	3	13	17

▶ NAIC 23965

58%

786

273

1,364

▶ KEMPER

58%

41,564

22,536

72,275

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
TRINITY UNIVERSAL INS CO	19887	55%	24,822	14,133	45,277
KEMPER INDEPENDENCE INS CO	10914	59%	10,965	5,582	18,738
UNITRIN AUTO & HOME INS CO	16063	78%	5,137	1,943	6,608
UNITED CAS INS CO OF AMER	11142	29%	315	696	1,092
MERASTAR INS CO	31968	69%	231	79	337
UNITRIN DIRECT PROP & CAS CO	10915	42%	82	95	197
UNITRIN DIRECT INS CO	10226	50%	11	8	22
RESPONSE INS CO	43044	25%	1	0	4

▶ PALISADES

57%

10,884

6,650

18,947

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
HIGH POINT PREFERRED INS CO	28959	58%	6,064	3,640	10,488
PALISADES PROP & CAS INS CO	10100	57%	4,816	3,010	8,452
PALISADES INS CO	10791	50%	2	0	4
TEACHERS AUTO INS CO	12212	67%	2	0	3

▶ NAIC 17450

57%

1,127

641

1,963

▶ LIBERTY MUTUAL

57%

567,289

342,365

990,660

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
LIBERTY MUT INS CO	23043	57%	282,032	170,491	492,792
PEERLESS INS CO	24198	57%	112,813	68,196	197,116
EMPLOYERS INS CO OF WAUSAU	21458	57%	45,125	27,279	78,847
LIBERTY MUT FIRE INS CO	23035	57%	45,125	27,279	78,847
OHIO CAS INS CO	24074	57%	45,125	27,279	78,847
SAFECO INS CO OF AMER	24740	57%	33,844	20,459	59,136
SAFECO INS CO OF OR	11071	64%	3,225	1,382	5,075

▶ MUNICH RE

57%

86,514

54,876

151,477

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
AMERICAN MODERN HOME INS CO	23469	56%	37,366	24,674	66,609
AMERICAN FAMILY HOME INS CO	23450	58%	32,958	20,232	56,940
AMERICAN MODERN PROP & CAS INS CO	42722	58%	10,823	6,603	18,583
AMERICAN SOUTHERN HOME INS CO	41998	58%	5,312	3,256	9,165
DIGITAL ADVANTAGE INS CO	34711	31%	55	111	180

▶ Stillwater Property and Casualty Insurance Company

57%

17,645

7,407

30,902

▶ NAIC 18309

57%

4,700

1,354

8,244

▶ CINCINNATI FINANCIAL

57%

59,085

18,690

103,813

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
THE CINCINNATI INS CO	10677	59%	42,343	12,234	72,199
THE CINCINNATI CAS CO	28665	53%	16,742	6,456	31,614

▶ AUTOMOBILE CLUB MI

57%

4,337

2,437

7,621

▶ Grange Insurance Association

57%

6,504

3,974

11,464

▶ Civil Service Employees Insurance Company

56%

2,722

1,580

4,824

▶ NAIC 10132

56%

1,735

985

3,075

▶ UTICA

55%

10,514

5,378

19,046

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
UTICA MUT INS CO	25976	55%	9,854	5,003	17,804
GRAPHIC ARTS MUT INS CO	25984	55%	484	255	879
FOUNDERS INS CO	14249	48%	80	54	165
REPUBLIC FRANKLIN INS CO	12475	48%	48	33	99
UTICA NATIONAL ASSUR CO	10687	48%	32	22	66
UTICA NATL INS CO OF TX	43478	48%	16	11	33

▶ US Coastal Property & Casualty Insurance Company

55%

5,966

2,338

10,877

▶ Countryway Insurance Company

55%

1,146

636

2,095

▶ NAIC 20125

54%

660

333

1,213

▶ California Casualty General Insurance Company of Oregon

54%

989

500

1,820

▶ NAIC 27464

54%

824

417

1,517

▶ NAIC 24201

54%

4,777

1,263

8,838

▶ AMERICAN FAMILY

54%

791,538

577,593

1,464,523

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
HOMESITE INS CO OF THE MIDWEST	13927	59%	455,796	263,501	777,691
AMERICAN FAMILY MUT INS CO SI	19275	57%	215,563	144,019	375,862
AMERICAN FAMILY CONNECT PROP & CAS I	29068	56%	52,632	34,397	93,207
HOMESITE INS CO	17221	56%	37,620	24,948	67,101
HOMESITE INS CO OF CA	11005	55%	32,157	20,493	58,002
AMERICAN FAMILY INS CO	10386	72%	38,733	12,671	53,487
HOMESITE IND CO	20419	53%	4,403	3,430	8,301
NGM INS CO	14788	76%	4,921	984	6,457
HOMESITE INS CO OF GA	10745	55%	3,117	2,194	5,689
HOMESITE INS CO OF FL	11156	57%	2,858	1,921	5,004
HOMESITE INS CO OF NY	10986	54%	2,693	1,867	4,993
HOMESITE LLOYDS OF TX	11237	-1474%	-61,914	65,927	4,201
AMERICAN STANDARD INS CO OF OH	10387	64%	1,616	774	2,532
MIDVALE IND CO	27138	71%	606	153	848
HOMESITE INS CO OF IL	11016	54%	336	217	621
AUSTIN MUT INS CO	13412	79%	238	48	302
AMERICAN FAMILY CONNECT INS CO	12504	72%	98	32	136
GRAIN DEALERS MUT INS CO	22098	73%	65	17	89

▶ Pekin Insurance Company

54%

1,194

316

2,210

▶ NAIC 15341

54%

1,437

665

2,667

▶ NAIC 17438

53%

633

366

1,202

▶ Aegis Security Insurance Company

52%

45,995

12,003

87,728

▶ IAT REINS CO GRP

52%

26,621

17,344

51,012

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
HARCO NATL INS CO	26433	52%	7,084	4,584	13,596
TRANSGUARD INS CO OF AMER INC	28886	52%	6,870	4,445	13,182
WILSHIRE INS CO	13234	52%	5,082	3,288	9,752
ACCEPTANCE IND INS CO	20010	53%	3,090	2,079	5,877
OCCIDENTAL FIRE & CAS CO OF NC	23248	52%	2,958	1,912	5,675
COMMERCIAL ALLIANCE INS CO	10906	53%	1,534	1,031	2,916
ACCEPTANCE CAS INS CO	10349	21%	3	5	14

▶ HARTFORD FIRE & CAS

52%

169,140

132,796

328,410

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
HARTFORD FIRE INS CO	19682	51%	80,792	63,572	157,031
HARTFORD ACCIDENT & IND CO	22357	51%	63,642	50,075	123,696
HARTFORD UNDERWRITERS INS CO	30104	51%	7,786	6,130	15,136
HARTFORD CAS INS CO	29424	52%	6,468	4,969	12,476
HARTFORD INS CO OF IL	38288	53%	3,359	2,507	6,335
TWIN CITY FIRE INS CO CO	29459	51%	2,920	2,297	5,676
PROPERTY & CAS INS CO OF HARTFORD	34690	51%	973	766	1,892
TRUMBULL INS CO	27120	51%	973	766	1,892
HARTFORD INS CO OF THE MIDWEST	37478	51%	758	602	1,486
PACIFIC INS CO LTD	10046	53%	565	422	1,066
SENTINEL INS CO LTD	11000	52%	502	389	965
NUTMEG INS CO	39608	53%	233	173	439
HARTFORD INS CO OF THE SOUTHEAST	38261	53%	166	125	314
HARTFORD LLOYDS INS CO	38253	50%	3	3	6

▶ Benchmark Insurance Company

51%

7,078

5,219

13,764

▶ FRONTLINE

51%

5,810

3,332

11,334

▶ ALLSTATE

51%

3,666,873

3,156,775

7,169,084

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
ALLSTATE INS CO	19232	51%	2,665,991	2,335,111	5,253,776
ALLSTATE IND CO	19240	49%	290,433	274,604	596,068
ALLSTATE VEHICLE & PROP INS CO	37907	51%	288,535	257,272	565,695
ALLSTATE PROP & CAS INS CO	17230	54%	144,043	106,591	264,592
ALLSTATE FIRE & CAS INS CO	29688	60%	60,942	37,768	100,887
INTEGON NATL INS CO	29742	61%	58,111	30,651	95,577
ESURANCE INS CO	25712	50%	17,664	16,188	35,608
MIC GEN	38660	62%	20,491	10,415	33,087
CASTLE KEY INS CO	30511	51%	14,185	12,089	27,816
ALLSTATE TX LLOYDS	26530	54%	13,259	10,443	24,370
ENCOMPASS INS CO	10358	63%	15,115	7,351	24,032
CASTLE KEY IND CO	10835	50%	11,985	10,667	23,981
ALLSTATE NJ INS CO	10852	44%	9,813	11,141	22,395
CENTURY NATL INS CO	26905	49%	10,779	9,186	21,943
ALLSTATE NJ PROP & CAS INS CO	14940	43%	6,810	8,104	15,975
NATIONAL FARMERS UNION PROP & CAS	16217	60%	8,463	4,001	14,164
ENCOMPASS IND CO	15130	70%	5,724	2,018	8,134
NATIONAL GEN INS CO	23728	54%	3,663	2,285	6,753
ESURANCE PROP & CAS INS CO	30210	41%	2,206	2,808	5,367
ENCOMPASS HOME & AUTO INS CO	11252	69%	3,426	1,224	4,962
ADIRONDACK INS EXCH	12583	55%	2,720	1,701	4,902
ENCOMPASS INS CO OF AMER	10071	79%	3,462	775	4,406
ENCOMPASS INDEPENDENT INS CO	11251	71%	3,095	1,084	4,371
IMPERIAL FIRE & CAS INS CO	44369	62%	2,068	1,038	3,320
NATIONAL GEN ASSUR CO	42447	57%	862	452	1,500
NEW JERSEY SKYLANDS INS ASSN	11454	62%	910	399	1,467
NORTH LIGHT SPECIALTY INS CO	13167	46%	498	519	1,084
ENCOMPASS PROP & CAS CO	10072	70%	383	109	549
ENCOMPASS PROP & CAS INS CO OF NJ	12496	55%	284	164	515
STANDARD PROP & CAS INS CO	15199	74%	375	116	506
INTEGON IND	22772	66%	220	76	333
INTEGON GEN	22780	36%	101	149	277
ENCOMPASS INS CO OF NJ	11599	62%	151	74	243
ALLSTATE N AMER INS CO	11110	8%	12	77	142
DIRECT GEN INS CO	42781	34%	35	18	103
DIRECT INS CO	37220	34%	21	38	61
ESURANCE INS CO OF NJ	21741	42%	23	29	55
INTEGON PREFERRED INS CO	31488	8%	3	32	38
DIRECT GEN INS CO OF MS	10889	38%	5	0	13
NEW SOUTH INS CO	12130	31%	4	8	13
INTEGON CAS INS CO	27930	50%	1	0	2
NATIONAL GEN PREMIER INS CO	12832	100%	2	0	2

▶ CUMIS Insurance Society, Inc.

51%

49,988

40,530

98,345

▶ FARMERS

51%

1,546,720

1,360,686

3,052,876

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
FARMERS INS EXCH	21652	48%	612,779	596,122	1,279,124
FOREMOST INS CO GRAND RAPIDS MI	11185	59%	407,978	261,736	694,724
MID CENTURY INS CO	21687	49%	189,457	184,308	390,039
TRUCK INS EXCH	21709	49%	91,769	89,274	186,923
FIRE INS EXCH	21660	48%	88,808	86,395	185,381
FARMERS INS CO OF OR	21636	46%	74,240	77,483	160,483
ECONOMY FIRE & CAS CO	22926	59%	19,941	11,801	33,634
CIVIC PROP & CAS CO	10315	48%	11,841	11,520	24,718
EXACT PROP & CAS CO INC	10318	48%	11,841	11,520	24,718
NEIGHBORHOOD SPIRIT PROP & CAS CO	10317	49%	11,841	11,520	24,396
FARMERS GRP PROP & CAS INS CO	34339	56%	12,693	8,756	22,842
FARMERS INS CO INC	21628	49%	7,416	7,164	15,188
FARMERS DIRECT PROP & CAS INS CO	25321	63%	4,981	1,932	7,899
21ST CENTURY PREMIER INS CO	20796	40%	1,135	1,155	2,807

▶ NAIC 24341

50%

3,599

2,362

7,202

▶ SECURA

50%

3,814

1,590

7,645

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
SECURA INS CO	22543	50%	3,433	1,431	6,881
SECURA SUPREME INS CO	10239	50%	381	159	764

▶ UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN

49%

3,417,063

3,320,026

6,925,637

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
USAA	25941	49%	1,409,043	1,385,621	2,869,916
USAA CAS INS CO	25968	49%	1,086,255	1,045,808	2,194,888
USAA GEN IND CO	18600	50%	601,311	579,342	1,212,284
GARRISON PROP & CAS INS CO	21253	49%	320,454	309,255	648,549

▶ NAIC 15997

49%

1,662

1,029

3,378

▶ MARKEL

49%

19,966

13,716

41,101

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
EVANSTON INS CO	35378	53%	6,220	3,306	11,785
MARKEL AMER INS CO	28932	52%	4,849	3,459	9,284
STATE NATL INS CO INC	12831	38%	2,738	2,593	7,113
MARKEL INS CO	38970	51%	3,065	1,972	6,023
NATIONAL SPECIALTY INS CO	22608	38%	1,369	1,296	3,556
SURETEC INS CO	10916	54%	435	255	809
UNITED SPECIALTY INS CO	12537	63%	475	205	757
CITY NATL INS CO	41335	43%	297	262	698
PINNACLE NAT INS CO	21296	43%	297	262	698
SUPERIOR SPECIALTY INS CO	16551	63%	136	58	216
FIRSTCOMP INS CO	27626	52%	85	48	162

▶ NAIC 15816

48%

2,212

1,669

4,568

▶ NAIC 16603

48%

1,729

1,361

3,593

▶ ASSURANT INC

48%

254,392

243,731

533,303

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
AMERICAN BANKERS INS CO OF FL	10111	48%	248,733	238,983	521,963
AMERICAN SECURITY INS CO	42978	50%	4,426	3,686	8,853
VOYAGER IND INS CO	40428	35%	481	819	1,387
STANDARD GUAR INS CO	42986	68%	752	243	1,100

▶ NAIC 32670

47%

2,841

982

5,990

▶ Oregon Mutual Insurance Company

47%

5,514

6,258

11,772

▶ NAIC 11048

45%

561

472

1,233

▶ PALOMAR HOLDINGS

45%

6,074

2,711

13,533

▶ NAIC 22390

44%

742

931

1,673

▶ ZURICH

44%

8,807

6,532

20,152

▶ NAIC 17030

43%

2,937

3,074

6,760

▶ Marysville Mutual Insurance Co.

43%

686

370

1,596

▶ NAIC 28290

43%

570

297

1,330

▶ Spinnaker Insurance Company

43%

69,394

76,636

162,363

▶ HOME STATE

43%

26,246

20,621

61,583

▶ NAIC 16825

42%

2,662

1,803

6,330

▶ NAIC 26166

40%

527

279

1,303

▶ NAIC 10048

40%

1,347

3,381

▶ DB Insurance Co., Ltd.(U.S. Branch)

40%

2,902

2,471

7,314

▶ NAIC 17360

40%

1,194

1,262

3,012

▶ Lemonade Insurance Company

36%

79,366

113,824

220,069

▶ MAPFRE

34%

16,342

23,443

47,375

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
COMMERCE INS CO	34754	33%	11,293	17,459	34,381
AMERICAN COMMERCE INS CO	19941	41%	3,299	3,571	8,051
COMMERCE W INS CO	13161	33%	1,043	1,607	3,170
MAPFRE INS CO	23876	40%	707	806	1,773

▶ NAIC 17522

32%

1,057

2,229

3,291

▶ IOWA FARM BUREAU

29%

26,399

63,208

89,607

▶ Seaview Insurance Company

29%

2,786

1,576

9,535

▶ NAIC 16848

29%

756

1,344

2,643

▶ NAIC 38148

27%

2,768

7,533

10,301

▶ Sutton National Insurance Company

26%

2,523

4,789

9,630

▶ First Acceptance Insurance Company, Inc.

23%

243

827

1,070

▶ KnightBrook Insurance Company

22%

894

2,053

4,103