Personal auto liability claim paid rates by group

The share of reported claims each insurer group closed with a payment — claims closed with payment ÷ claims reported — from countrywide annual statements, summed across every member company and available year. Click a group to see its member companies. Claims a carrier is still sitting on count against its paid rate; groups with fewer than 1000 reported claims are excluded.

42% of reported personal auto liability claims across 139 groups closed with a payment

Group

Companies

Paid rate

Closed paid

Closed unpaid

Reported

▶ CHUBB

76%

45,347

3,314

60,028

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
ACE AMER INS CO	22667	76%	10,507	735	13,910
FEDERAL INS CO	20281	76%	10,507	735	13,910
ACE PROP & CAS INS CO	20699	76%	8,405	588	11,127
PACIFIC IND CO	20346	76%	8,405	588	11,127
EXECUTIVE RISK IND INC	35181	76%	4,203	295	5,564
CHUBB IND INS CO	12777	80%	1,852	126	2,323
VIGILANT INS CO	20397	76%	1,395	95	1,828
CENTURY IND CO	20710	0%	0	148	148
CHUBB LLOYDS INS CO OF TX	27774	80%	73	4	91

▶ NAIC 16713

75%

784

161

1,043

▶ Stillwater Insurance Company

71%

2,949

4,127

▶ AIG

71%

6,882

742

9,723

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
NATIONAL UNION FIRE INS CO OF PITTSB	19445	71%	3,254	338	4,566
AMERICAN HOME ASSUR CO	19380	71%	3,027	351	4,286
LEXINGTON INS CO	19437	69%	418	35	605
COMMERCE & INDUSTRY INS CO	19410	69%	183	18	266

▶ NAIC 41475

70%

2,010

243

2,859

▶ Stillwater Property and Casualty Insurance Company

70%

1,113

1,584

▶ CENTRAL MUT INS CO GRP

69%

19,060

2,402

27,469

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
CENTRAL MUT INS CO	20230	69%	16,011	2,018	23,075
ALL AMER INS CO	20222	69%	3,049	384	4,394

▶ NAIC 18686

68%

885

1,293

▶ NAIC 14257

67%

1,956

297

2,918

▶ NAIC 15831

66%

2,707

215

4,080

▶ Grinnell Mutual Reinsurance Company

66%

9,000

631

13,629

▶ FRANKENMUTH GRP

65%

7,004

1,928

10,768

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
FRANKENMUTH INS CO	13986	65%	6,712	1,814	10,278
ANSUR AMER	10984	60%	146	57	245
PATRIOT INS CO	32069	60%	146	57	245

▶ Grinnell Select Insurance Company

65%

5,112

326

7,863

▶ NAIC 13781

65%

1,002

327

1,545

▶ NAIC 10891

64%

1,696

573

2,666

▶ NAIC 13072

61%

1,420

197

2,341

▶ Virginia Farm Bureau Town & Country Insurance Company

61%

1,061

235

1,751

▶ NAIC 26026

61%

1,061

235

1,751

▶ Virginia Farm Bureau Mutual Insurance Company

61%

3,182

705

5,253

▶ AMTRUST FINANCIAL SERV GRP

60%

8,117

2,121

13,525

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
TECHNOLOGY INS CO INC	42376	59%	4,792	1,340	8,096
WESCO INS CO	25011	60%	1,984	508	3,302
DEVELOPERS SURETY & IND CO	12718	61%	759	183	1,251
SECURITY NATL INS COMPANY	19879	66%	580	90	874
SOUTHERN INS CO	19216	100%	2	0	2

▶ Pharmacists Mutual Insurance Company

59%

697

111

1,185

▶ NORTH CAROLINA FARM BUREAU

58%

94,221

29,719

161,676

▶ CINCINNATI FINANCIAL

58%

49,768

9,268

86,480

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
THE CINCINNATI INS CO	10677	59%	35,963	6,425	60,891
THE CINCINNATI CAS CO	28665	54%	13,798	2,843	25,581
THE CINCINNATI IND CO	23280	88%	7	0	8

▶ NAIC 14850

58%

3,501

592

6,088

▶ DONEGAL

57%

14,182

5,027

24,863

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
ATLANTIC STATES INS CO	22586	58%	7,604	2,666	13,071
DONEGAL MUT INS CO	13692	58%	4,300	1,483	7,414
SOUTHERN INS CO OF VA	26867	53%	1,403	499	2,640
PENINSULA INS CO	14958	50%	489	230	972
MICHIGAN INS CO	10857	46%	218	113	470
SOUTHERN MUT INS CO	15172	57%	168	36	296

▶ BROOKFIELD REINS LTD GRP

56%

53,198

22,782

94,473

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
AMERICAN NATIONAL PROP & CAS CO	28401	57%	48,243	20,530	84,728
AMERICAN NATL GEN INS CO	39942	53%	3,697	1,531	6,958
ARGONAUT INS CO	19801	45%	1,258	721	2,787

▶ Columbia Mutual Insurance Company

56%

679

247

1,218

▶ NAIC 24201

56%

3,316

891

5,960

▶ Pekin Insurance Company

56%

829

223

1,490

▶ FARMERS

55%

1,983,432

905,097

3,583,626

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
FARMERS INS EXCH	21652	57%	922,497	374,638	1,625,628
MID CENTURY INS CO	21687	61%	285,216	115,830	469,275
FOREMOST INS CO GRAND RAPIDS MI	11185	45%	124,457	98,074	276,425
FIRE INS EXCH	21660	57%	133,694	54,297	235,598
COAST NATL INS CO	25089	45%	102,681	74,801	229,137
TRUCK INS EXCH	21709	62%	138,153	56,104	222,725
FARMERS INS CO OF OR	21636	55%	115,960	52,681	212,381
ECONOMY FIRE & CAS CO	22926	45%	26,445	17,673	59,331
FARMERS GRP PROP & CAS INS CO	34339	48%	24,466	14,129	51,217
21ST CENTURY INS CO	12963	61%	24,835	4,233	40,907
CIVIC PROP & CAS CO	10315	57%	17,826	7,240	31,414
EXACT PROP & CAS CO INC	10318	57%	17,826	7,240	31,414
NEIGHBORHOOD SPIRIT PROP & CAS CO	10317	59%	17,826	7,241	30,192
21ST CENTURY CAS CO	36404	37%	8,919	9,890	23,883
FARMERS INS CO INC	21628	53%	8,418	4,043	15,743
21ST CENTURY CENTENNIAL INS CO	34789	55%	7,961	3,303	14,552
FARMERS DIRECT PROP & CAS INS CO	25321	45%	6,108	3,637	13,589
21ST CENTURY PREMIER INS CO	20796	78%	131	16	168
21ST CENTURY N AMER INS CO	32220	28%	13	27	47

▶ WESTFIELD

55%

14,065

4,162

25,730

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
WESTFIELD NATL INS CO	24120	55%	6,527	1,917	11,839
WESTFIELD INS CO	24112	54%	4,679	1,393	8,622
OHIO FARMERS INS CO	24104	54%	1,646	491	3,034
OLD GUARD INS CO	17558	54%	780	232	1,437
AMERICAN SELECT INS CO	19992	54%	433	129	798

▶ SENTRY

54%

406,069

179,718

749,932

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
SENTRY INS CO	24988	54%	334,461	149,187	617,081
MIDDLESEX INS CO	23434	54%	26,765	11,344	49,450
SENTRY SELECT INS CO	21180	53%	20,776	8,905	38,948
VIKING INS CO OF WI	13137	54%	13,384	5,671	24,726
SENTRY CAS CO	28460	54%	6,691	2,835	12,362
FLORISTS MUT INS CO	13978	54%	3,992	1,776	7,365

▶ NAIC 27022

54%

868

307

1,605

▶ WEST BEND INS CO

54%

25,155

8,638

46,649

▶ NAIC 15449

54%

4,863

2,952

9,035

▶ NAIC 29246

53%

13,180

3,045

24,813

▶ NAIC 13131

53%

2,248

854

4,281

▶ SELECTIVE

52%

8,003

3,730

15,263

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
SELECTIVE INS CO OF AMER	12572	53%	5,690	2,621	10,715
SELECTIVE WAY INS CO	26301	51%	715	342	1,404
SELECTIVE INS CO OF SC	19259	51%	306	147	602
SELECTIVE CAS INS CO	14376	51%	238	114	468
SELECTIVE INS CO OF NY	13730	51%	238	114	468
SELECTIVE INS CO OF THE SOUTHEAST	39926	51%	238	114	468
SELECTIVE AUTO INS CO OF NJ	11074	51%	204	98	401
MESA UNDERWRITERS SPECIALTY INS CO	36838	51%	170	82	335
SELECTIVE FIRE & CAS INS CO	14377	51%	102	49	201
SELECTIVE INS CO OF NEW ENGLAND	11867	51%	102	49	201

▶ KENTUCKY FARM BUREAU

52%

12,213

3,291

23,418

▶ AMERICAN FAMILY

52%

575,154

277,985

1,112,077

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
AMERICAN FAMILY CONNECT PROP & CAS I	29068	49%	183,660	107,020	373,656
AMERICAN FAMILY MUT INS CO SI	19275	55%	174,192	72,560	315,849
PERMANENT GEN ASSUR	37648	48%	135,732	72,294	282,830
AMERICAN FAMILY INS CO	10386	62%	48,260	13,533	78,461
NGM INS CO	14788	57%	12,101	3,478	21,182
PERMANENT GEN ASSUR CORP OF OH	22906	51%	8,105	4,104	15,819
THE GEN AUTOMOBILE INS CO INC	13703	52%	4,239	1,923	8,109
MIDVALE IND CO	27138	61%	4,365	1,047	7,206
AMERICAN STANDARD INS CO OF OH	10387	54%	2,632	997	4,907
AMERICAN FAMILY CONNECT INS CO	12504	40%	937	655	2,315
AMERICAN STANDARD INS CO OF WI	19283	61%	438	163	715
GRAIN DEALERS MUT INS CO	22098	49%	198	52	404
HOMESITE INS CO OF GA	10745	40%	150	125	379
AUSTIN MUT INS CO	13412	59%	145	34	245

▶ Enumclaw Property & Casualty Insurance Company

51%

857

417

1,675

▶ ACUITY A MUT INS CO

51%

5,154

1,856

10,077

▶ ENCOVA MUTUAL

51%

2,010

604

3,936

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
MOTORISTS COMMERCIAL MUT INS CO	13331	55%	959	287	1,750
BRICKSTREET MUT INS CO	12372	48%	584	177	1,217
MOTORISTS MUT INS CO	14621	48%	292	88	608
CONSUMERS INS USA INC	10204	48%	23	7	48
IOWA MUT INS CO	14338	48%	23	7	48
MICO INS CO	40932	49%	21	6	43
PINNACLEPOINT INS CO	15137	49%	21	6	43
SUMMITPOINT INS CO	15136	49%	21	6	43
ALLEGHENYPOINT INS CO	13016	49%	17	5	35
PHENIX MUT FIRE INS CO	23175	49%	17	5	35
NORTHSTONE INS CO	13045	48%	16	5	33
WILSON MUT INS CO	19950	48%	16	5	33

▶ NAIC 11048

51%

924

415

1,818

▶ SECURA

50%

1,914

749

3,807

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
SECURA INS CO	22543	50%	1,723	674	3,427
SECURA SUPREME INS CO	10239	50%	191	75	380

▶ NAIC 14761

50%

4,719

2,584

9,388

▶ AUTO CLUB ENTERPRISES

49%

571,497

291,347

1,159,095

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
INTERINS EXCH OF THE AUTOMOBILE CLUB	15598	49%	567,606	289,421	1,151,178
AUTOMOBILE CLUB INTERINS EXCH	15512	49%	3,891	1,926	7,917

▶ HARTFORD FIRE & CAS

49%

238,703

127,404

487,365

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
HARTFORD FIRE INS CO	19682	49%	113,565	60,441	231,632
HARTFORD ACCIDENT & IND CO	22357	49%	89,457	47,609	182,460
HARTFORD UNDERWRITERS INS CO	30104	49%	11,014	5,826	22,394
HARTFORD CAS INS CO	29424	48%	9,921	5,477	20,525
HARTFORD INS CO OF IL	38288	48%	4,729	2,667	9,846
TWIN CITY FIRE INS CO CO	29459	49%	4,104	2,184	8,372
PROPERTY & CAS INS CO OF HARTFORD	34690	49%	1,368	729	2,791
TRUMBULL INS CO	27120	49%	1,368	729	2,791
HARTFORD INS CO OF THE MIDWEST	37478	48%	1,130	619	2,337
PACIFIC INS CO LTD	10046	48%	796	449	1,657
SENTINEL INS CO LTD	11000	50%	684	355	1,381
NUTMEG INS CO	39608	48%	328	184	682
HARTFORD INS CO OF THE SOUTHEAST	38261	48%	234	132	487
HARTFORD LLOYDS INS CO	38253	50%	5	3	10

▶ TRAVELERS

48%

471,478

117,418

973,394

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
ST PAUL FIRE & MARINE INS CO	24767	49%	142,300	34,801	291,659
TRAVELERS CAS & SURETY CO	19038	49%	116,874	28,585	239,544
TRAVELERS IND CO	25658	48%	99,694	25,994	209,546
STANDARD FIRE INS CO	19070	49%	23,327	5,751	47,708
UNITED STATES FIDELITY & GUAR CO	25887	48%	21,498	5,483	45,042
TRAVELERS CAS INS CO OF AMER	19046	49%	13,157	3,245	26,907
TRAVELERS IND CO OF CT	25682	49%	7,857	1,923	16,110
FARMINGTON CAS CO	41483	48%	7,211	1,839	15,109
NORTHLAND INS CO	24015	49%	7,004	1,707	14,345
PHOENIX INS CO	25623	49%	5,290	1,304	10,858
ST PAUL PROTECTIVE INS CO	19224	48%	2,825	721	5,918
TRAVELERS COMMERCIAL INS CO	36137	49%	2,693	658	5,519
CHARTER OAK FIRE INS CO	25615	48%	2,593	657	5,386
TRAVELERS CAS CO OF CT	36170	48%	2,287	584	4,793
TRAVELERS COMMERCIAL CAS CO	40282	48%	2,287	584	4,793
TRAVELERS PROP CAS CO OF AMER	25674	49%	2,059	496	4,214
ST PAUL MERCURY INS CO	24791	48%	1,944	490	4,071
TRAVELERS PROP CAS INS CO	36161	49%	1,719	412	3,514
AUTOMOBILE INS CO OF HARTFORD CT	19062	49%	1,447	356	2,972
THE TRAVELERS CAS CO	41769	48%	1,412	357	2,952
TRAVELERS CONSTITUTION STATE INS CO	41750	48%	1,412	357	2,952
TRAVELERS IND CO OF AMER	25666	49%	814	202	1,672
NORTHLAND CAS CO	24031	48%	679	169	1,419
TRAVCO PERSONAL INS CO	36463	48%	679	169	1,419
FIDELITY & GUAR INS UNDERWRITERS INC	25879	48%	482	117	1,000
ST PAUL GUARDIAN INS CO	24775	48%	482	117	1,000
FIRST FLORIDIAN AUTO & HOME INS CO	10647	48%	308	60	636
TRAVCO INS CO	28188	49%	286	70	584
TRAVELERS HOME & MARINE INS CO	27998	49%	286	70	584
TRAVELERS PERSONAL INS CO	38130	49%	286	70	584
TRAVELERS PERSONAL SECURITY INS CO	36145	49%	286	70	584

▶ CNA

48%

744

1,546

▶ NAIC 15091

48%

645

324

1,346

▶ FAIRFAX FINANCIAL

48%

1,121

777

2,341

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
UNITED STATES FIRE INS CO	21113	48%	861	595	1,797
NORTH RIVER INS CO	21105	48%	249	174	521
CRUM & FORSTER IND CO	31348	48%	11	8	23

▶ NAIC 14044

48%

2,057

961

4,298

▶ NAIC 24341

47%

10,793

6,182

22,813

▶ NAIC 26859

47%

3,382

2,739

7,225

▶ THE HANOVER

47%

145,250

80,706

311,404

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
HANOVER INS CO	22292	46%	84,242	48,427	182,267
CITIZENS INS CO OF AMER	31534	47%	31,692	16,515	67,964
ALLMERICA FIN BENEFIT INS CO	41840	50%	15,694	7,958	31,571
HANOVER AMER INS CO	36064	49%	6,595	3,138	13,417
CITIZENS INS CO OF THE MIDWEST	10395	42%	3,778	2,674	9,070
ALLMERICA FIN ALLIANCE INS CO	10212	46%	3,155	1,943	6,922
MASSACHUSETTS BAY INS CO	22306	49%	93	48	189
CITIZENS INS CO OF IL	10714	25%	1	3	4

▶ Ocean Harbor Casualty Insurance Company

46%

55,178

28,656

120,388

▶ Benchmark Insurance Company

45%

673

201

1,484

▶ AMICA MUTUAL

45%

127,483

61,936

281,286

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
AMICA MUT INS CO	19976	45%	126,240	61,157	277,931
AMICA PROP & CAS INS CO	12287	37%	1,243	779	3,355

▶ ALFA

45%

27,073

11,940

59,940

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
ALFA MUT INS CO	19135	48%	10,405	3,542	21,880
ALFA MUT FIRE INS CO	19143	48%	9,414	3,205	19,797
ARIZONA AUTOMOBILE INS CO	11805	29%	2,300	3,507	7,844
ALFA MUT GEN INS CO	19151	48%	1,486	506	3,125
ALFA GEN	41661	48%	991	337	2,084
TREXIS	12188	48%	991	337	2,084
ALFA	22330	48%	743	253	1,563
TREXIS ONE	11004	48%	743	253	1,563

▶ AUTO OWNERS

45%

10,253

7,648

22,754

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
CALIFORNIA CAPITAL INS CO	13544	39%	4,799	5,074	12,305
CONCORD GEN MUT INS CO	20672	67%	2,757	256	4,140
EAGLE W INS CO	12890	39%	1,260	1,330	3,230
MONTEREY INS CO	23540	39%	865	914	2,218
GREEN MOUNTAIN INS CO INC	20680	66%	572	74	861

▶ NAIC 12966

45%

4,204

3,441

9,337

▶ NAIC 15997

45%

1,840

1,260

4,092

▶ NAIC 13721

44%

1,719

1,242

3,877

▶ BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY

44%

7,731,098

4,745,455

17,705,097

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
NATIONAL IND CO	20087	44%	2,626,452	1,615,368	6,035,734
GOVERNMENT EMPLOYEES INS CO	22063	44%	2,644,000	1,668,484	5,999,555
GEICO GEN INS CO	35882	43%	1,119,509	672,182	2,618,009
GEICO CAS CO	41491	45%	664,152	374,142	1,476,356
GEICO IND CO	22055	42%	597,224	380,897	1,412,163
GEICO ADVANTAGE INS CO	14138	48%	52,250	25,847	108,531
GEICO MARINE INS CO	37923	38%	12,171	6,165	32,383
BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY SPECIALTY INS CO	22276	78%	11,567	753	14,908
BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY HOMESTATE INS CO	20044	52%	3,679	1,555	7,040
NATIONAL LIAB & FIRE INS CO	20052	22%	94	62	418

▶ MERCURY GEN

44%

208,275

125,590

477,824

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
MERCURY INS CO	27553	42%	118,536	80,393	283,222
MERCURY CAS CO	11908	46%	49,162	23,425	106,277
CALIFORNIA AUTOMOBILE INS CO	38342	44%	20,534	12,187	46,588
AMERICAN MERCURY INS CO	16810	53%	9,978	3,858	18,957
ORION IND CO	13250	32%	2,618	3,220	8,291
MERCURY IND CO OF AMER	11201	50%	3,256	1,085	6,549
MERCURY CNTY MUT INS CO	29394	54%	2,073	745	3,818
MERCURY IND CO OF GA	10015	53%	1,695	447	3,179
MERCURY INS CO OF IL	34444	45%	423	230	943

▶ NAIC 11558

43%

28,838

25,725

66,309

▶ WR BERKLEY

43%

1,755

771

4,036

▶ CSAA

43%

404,821

229,331

938,509

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
CSAA INS EXCH	15539	43%	343,187	196,270	791,121
CSAA GEN INS CO	37770	42%	53,251	29,075	127,553
CSAA FIRE & CAS INS CO	10921	43%	7,369	3,443	17,237
CSAA AFFINITY INS CO	11681	39%	1,014	543	2,597
MOBILITAS GEN INS CO	10675	0%	0	0	1

▶ RANDALL & QUILTER INVESTMENT

43%

1,355

1,100

3,143

▶ PROGRESSIVE

43%

7,018,420

5,981,063

16,365,285

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
PROGRESSIVE DIRECT INS CO	16322	42%	2,736,522	2,469,782	6,580,651
PROGRESSIVE CAS INS CO	24260	45%	1,890,862	1,463,925	4,188,113
PROGRESSIVE SELECT INS CO	10192	41%	695,487	656,036	1,686,768
PROGRESSIVE NORTHWESTERN INS CO	42919	45%	395,956	310,100	883,850
UNITED FINANCIAL CAS CO	11770	40%	268,840	249,068	676,958
PROGRESSIVE SPECIALTY INS CO	32786	45%	230,975	180,890	515,579
PROGRESSIVE CNTY MUT INS CO	29203	47%	166,606	123,467	352,100
PROGRESSIVE ADVANCED INS CO	11851	41%	123,898	112,156	299,364
DRIVE INS CO	27804	38%	90,179	84,361	235,933
PROGRESSIVE NORTHERN INS CO	38628	46%	78,728	58,493	170,977
PROGRESSIVE PREFERRED INS CO	37834	46%	39,364	29,246	85,488
PROGRESSIVE MARATHON INS CO	37605	43%	35,533	29,983	82,899
PROGRESSIVE MAX INS CO	24279	43%	35,533	29,983	82,899
PROGRESSIVE GARDEN STATE INS CO	14800	36%	27,098	29,519	74,293
PROGRESSIVE MI INS CO	10187	46%	26,243	19,497	56,992
PROGRESSIVE UNIVERSAL INS CO	21727	43%	23,688	19,989	55,266
PROGRESSIVE CLASSIC INS CO	42994	46%	19,682	14,623	42,744
ARTISAN & TRUCKERS CAS CO	10194	45%	17,891	12,834	39,477
PROGRESSIVE SECURITY INS CO	10050	49%	19,016	11,056	38,513
MOUNTAIN LAUREL ASSUR CO	44180	46%	13,909	10,550	29,956
PROGRESSIVE AMER INS CO	24252	46%	13,121	9,749	28,496
PROGRESSIVE GULF INS CO	42412	46%	13,121	9,749	28,496
PROGRESSIVE PREMIER INS CO OF IL	21735	43%	11,844	9,995	27,633
DRIVE NJ INS CO	11410	36%	8,329	8,744	23,043
PROGRESSIVE HI	10067	47%	10,245	7,398	21,798
PROGRESSIVE MOUNTAIN INS CO	35190	46%	6,561	4,874	14,248
PROGRESSIVE SOUTHEASTERN INS CO	38784	46%	6,561	4,874	14,248
PROGRESSIVE BAYSIDE INS CO	17350	46%	3,280	2,437	7,124
PROGRESSIVE FREEDOM INS CO	12302	46%	3,280	2,437	7,124
PROGRESSIVE CHOICE INS CO	44288	43%	2,961	2,498	6,908
PROGRESSIVE PALOVERDE INS CO	44695	43%	2,961	2,498	6,908
PROGRESSIVE EXPRESS INS CO	10193	33%	142	249	429
ASI HOME	11072	50%	3	2	6
AMERICAN STRATEGIC	10872	0%	0	0	2
ASI SELECT	14042	50%	1	1	2

▶ NAIC 18309

43%

1,093

2,549

▶ MS & AD

43%

696

462

1,636

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
DTRIC INS CO LTD	37265	42%	682	455	1,615
TRANSVERSE INS CO	21075	67%	14	7	21

▶ TOKIO MARINE HOLDINGS INC

42%

2,968

2,084

7,036

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
FIRST INS CO OF HI LTD	41742	34%	818	881	2,440
PHILADELPHIA IND INS CO	18058	48%	1,092	742	2,260
TOKIO MARINE AMER INS CO	10945	47%	922	384	1,975
TRANS PACIFIC INS CO	41238	38%	136	77	361

▶ NAIC 28339

42%

3,377

3,059

8,043

▶ Countryway Insurance Company

42%

757

405

1,814

▶ NAIC 12878

42%

5,884

6,310

14,156

▶ UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN

41%

2,997,563

3,121,417

7,287,411

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
USAA CAS INS CO	25968	41%	1,100,582	1,165,450	2,708,805
USAA	25941	42%	990,111	1,009,572	2,364,460
USAA GEN IND CO	18600	41%	581,694	606,123	1,419,138
GARRISON PROP & CAS INS CO	21253	41%	324,763	339,959	794,001
NOBLR RECIP EXCH	16461	41%	413	313	1,007

▶ NAIC 23337

41%

422

289

1,039

▶ ERIE

39%

87,402

26,914

221,403

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
ERIE INS EXCH	26271	39%	79,131	24,560	200,675
ERIE INS CO	26263	39%	4,187	1,299	10,617
ERIE INS PROP & CAS CO	26830	41%	3,665	925	9,049
ERIE INS CO OF NY	16233	39%	419	130	1,062

▶ California Casualty Indemnity Exchange

39%

38,298

35,670

98,747

▶ MARKEL

39%

39,325

32,504

102,102

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
ESSENTIA INS CO	37915	42%	19,056	16,455	45,061
EVANSTON INS CO	35378	44%	7,941	5,739	18,045
STATE NATL INS CO INC	12831	26%	3,284	2,487	12,421
MARKEL INS CO	38970	39%	3,231	3,076	8,262
NATIONAL SPECIALTY INS CO	22608	26%	1,643	1,241	6,209
MARKEL AMER INS CO	28932	39%	2,102	1,980	5,377
CITY NATL INS CO	41335	26%	542	401	2,048
PINNACLE NAT INS CO	21296	26%	542	401	2,048
SURETEC INS CO	10916	39%	467	452	1,199
UNITED SPECIALTY INS CO	12537	36%	343	152	963
SUPERIOR SPECIALTY INS CO	16551	36%	98	43	275
FIRSTCOMP INS CO	27626	39%	76	77	194

▶ KEMPER

38%

893,657

968,063

2,343,412

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
TRINITY UNIVERSAL INS CO	19887	38%	444,865	475,019	1,158,571
INFINITY INS CO	22268	38%	394,683	437,443	1,050,228
FINANCIAL IND CO	19852	34%	30,868	40,563	90,590
KEMPER INDEPENDENCE INS CO	10914	51%	15,949	10,693	31,357
UNITRIN AUTO & HOME INS CO	16063	69%	4,492	2,045	6,484
UNITRIN DIRECT INS CO	10226	47%	1,331	1,061	2,862
UNITRIN DIRECT PROP & CAS CO	10915	47%	522	381	1,111
INFINITY SELECT INS CO	20260	39%	398	442	1,022
MERASTAR INS CO	31968	52%	288	173	549
RESPONSE INS CO	43044	47%	189	132	399
INFINITY AUTO INS CO	11738	30%	72	111	239

▶ AUTOMOBILE CLUB MI

38%

2,268

2,053

6,024

▶ NAIC 22128

38%

733

780

1,947

▶ Root Insurance Company

38%

76,976

93,224

205,050

▶ ALLSTATE

37%

7,009,829

8,989,146

18,697,524

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
ALLSTATE INS CO	19232	37%	3,416,183	4,588,508	9,334,833
ALLSTATE FIRE & CAS INS CO	29688	39%	1,468,067	1,833,862	3,785,842
ALLSTATE PROP & CAS INS CO	17230	38%	559,565	727,195	1,490,735
ALLSTATE NORTHBROOK IND CO	36455	30%	320,829	599,029	1,056,574
ALLSTATE IND CO	19240	38%	243,889	309,719	639,728
INTEGON NATL INS CO	29742	39%	216,478	212,106	553,520
DIRECT GEN INS CO	42781	46%	231,943	195,912	505,683
ESURANCE PROP & CAS INS CO	30210	41%	149,897	137,632	362,195
INTEGON PREFERRED INS CO	31488	44%	77,726	62,109	174,868
SAFE AUTO INS CO	25405	29%	40,811	71,349	138,639
INTEGON IND	22772	48%	55,767	37,954	115,068
ESURANCE INS CO	25712	41%	35,510	30,676	86,279
INTEGON GEN	22780	46%	27,746	20,294	59,962
ALLSTATE NJ INS CO	10852	31%	17,616	30,862	57,148
ALLSTATE NJ PROP & CAS INS CO	14940	30%	13,855	26,124	46,700
NATIONAL GEN INS CO	23728	41%	19,210	18,481	46,689
ENCOMPASS INS CO	10358	45%	19,564	15,272	43,025
NATIONAL FARMERS UNION PROP & CAS	16217	59%	14,897	6,753	25,202
NATIONAL GEN PREMIER INS CO	12832	46%	10,642	8,784	23,139
NATIONAL GEN ASSUR CO	42447	47%	10,509	8,080	22,145
MIC GEN	38660	47%	8,955	6,627	18,905
DIRECT INS CO	37220	43%	5,944	6,103	13,869
NEW SOUTH INS CO	12130	42%	5,778	4,812	13,628
CENTURY NATL INS CO	26905	50%	6,126	3,999	12,356
IMPERIAL FIRE & CAS INS CO	44369	46%	4,626	3,540	9,979
ALLSTATE CNTY MUT INS CO	29335	40%	3,614	4,225	9,013
ENCOMPASS HOME & AUTO INS CO	11252	51%	3,973	2,768	7,808
ENCOMPASS IND CO	15130	53%	3,940	2,368	7,436
ENCOMPASS INDEPENDENT INS CO	11251	51%	3,100	1,891	6,021
ADIRONDACK INS EXCH	12583	50%	2,643	1,857	5,325
ESURANCE INS CO OF NJ	21741	37%	1,922	2,254	5,240
NATIONAL GENERAL INS ONLINE INC	11044	41%	1,983	1,876	4,822
DIRECT GEN INS CO OF MS	10889	43%	1,912	1,979	4,484
INTEGON CAS INS CO	27930	47%	1,318	1,024	2,833
ALLSTATE N AMER INS CO	11110	29%	746	1,359	2,538
ENCOMPASS INS CO OF AMER	10071	55%	1,168	678	2,142
ENCOMPASS PROP & CAS INS CO OF NJ	12496	38%	500	494	1,317
ENCOMPASS PROP & CAS CO	10072	49%	289	198	584
NEW JERSEY SKYLANDS INS ASSN	11454	45%	175	137	385
DIRECT NATL INS CO	23736	30%	92	91	306
STANDARD PROP & CAS INS CO	15199	58%	169	98	291
ENCOMPASS INS CO OF NJ	11599	52%	97	55	185
AGENT ALLIANCE INS CO	10389	66%	55	12	83

▶ NAIC 27464

37%

1,707

1,586

4,580

▶ NAIC 20125

37%

1,365

1,270

3,664

▶ California Casualty General Insurance Company of Oregon

37%

2,047

1,906

5,496

▶ MUNICH RE

37%

1,103

548

2,992

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
AMERICAN MODERN HOME INS CO	23469	37%	475	216	1,272
AMERICAN FAMILY HOME INS CO	23450	37%	364	169	987
AMERICAN MODERN PROP & CAS INS CO	42722	37%	120	54	327
MUNICH REINS AMER INC	10227	35%	87	80	246
AMERICAN SOUTHERN HOME INS CO	41998	36%	57	29	160

▶ Metromile Insurance Company

37%

16,026

15,849

43,579

▶ LIBERTY MUTUAL

37%

582,378

710,746

1,590,958

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
LIBERTY MUT INS CO	23043	37%	289,011	352,819	789,431
PEERLESS INS CO	24198	37%	115,604	141,127	315,772
EMPLOYERS INS CO OF WAUSAU	21458	37%	46,241	56,452	126,309
LIBERTY MUT FIRE INS CO	23035	37%	46,241	56,452	126,309
OHIO CAS INS CO	24074	37%	46,241	56,452	126,309
SAFECO INS CO OF AMER	24740	37%	34,681	42,339	94,732
SAFECO INS CO OF OR	11071	36%	4,359	5,105	12,096

▶ Quincy Mutual Fire Insurance Company

36%

2,412

2,230

6,620

▶ NATIONWIDE

36%

543,678

744,218

1,508,454

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
NATIONWIDE MUT INS CO	23787	36%	502,462	687,100	1,393,250
NATIONWIDE AGRIBUSINESS INS CO	28223	36%	18,738	25,503	51,934
NATIONAL CAS CO	11991	36%	6,246	8,502	17,312
NATIONWIDE INS CO OF AMER	25453	36%	6,246	8,502	17,312
NATIONWIDE GEN INS CO	23760	35%	4,966	7,040	14,088
COLONIAL CNTY MUT INS CO	29262	37%	4,801	6,449	12,965
TITAN INS CO	36269	14%	219	1,122	1,593

▶ Grange Insurance Association

35%

3,276

4,088

9,273

▶ NAIC 23965

35%

768

2,194

▶ TRISURA

35%

6,417

7,841

18,423

▶ NAIC 14133

35%

6,867

7,014

19,847

▶ NAIC 23779

35%

55,249

78,301

159,838

▶ Civil Service Employees Insurance Company

34%

995

1,362

2,901

▶ NAIC 14254

34%

7,167

8,770

20,906

▶ Spinnaker Insurance Company

34%

1,549

2,268

4,551

▶ NAIC 24503

34%

31,872

45,219

93,655

▶ MICHIGAN FARM BUREAU

34%

3,584

3,720

10,533

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
FARM BUREAU GEN INS CO OF MI	21547	34%	2,446	2,558	7,192
FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO OF MI	21555	34%	1,138	1,162	3,341

▶ NAIC 13683

34%

396

184

1,182

▶ NAIC 13127

33%

8,021

10,670

24,186

▶ CUMIS Insurance Society, Inc.

32%

72,491

102,373

229,173

▶ NAIC 20400

32%

630

534

1,995

▶ NAIC 16999

31%

1,801

1,266

5,735

▶ NAIC 19119

31%

2,403

3,971

7,854

▶ NAIC 16825

30%

2,765

5,147

9,151

▶ UTICA

30%

32,149

49,437

108,390

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
UTICA MUT INS CO	25976	30%	30,091	46,012	101,130
GRAPHIC ARTS MUT INS CO	25984	29%	1,445	2,333	5,024
FOUNDERS INS CO	14249	27%	279	496	1,016
REPUBLIC FRANKLIN INS CO	12475	27%	167	298	610
UTICA NATIONAL ASSUR CO	10687	27%	111	199	407
UTICA NATL INS CO OF TX	43478	28%	56	99	203

▶ Aegis Security Insurance Company

29%

686

742

2,348

▶ NAIC 10920

29%

76,519

127,874

262,615

▶ NAIC 37028

29%

3,533

4,437

12,354

▶ KnightBrook Insurance Company

29%

5,328

6,670

18,667

▶ INCLINE INS GRP LLC GRP

28%

9,183

18,405

32,541

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
INCLINE CAS CO	11090	37%	6,739	11,113	18,234
INCLINE NATL INS CO	19269	17%	2,444	7,292	14,307

▶ IAT REINS CO GRP

28%

559

1,057

2,010

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
HARCO NATL INS CO	26433	28%	175	336	629
TRANSGUARD INS CO OF AMER INC	28886	28%	169	326	609
WILSHIRE INS CO	13234	28%	125	241	451
OCCIDENTAL FIRE & CAS CO OF NC	23248	28%	73	141	263
ACCEPTANCE IND INS CO	20010	28%	11	9	39
COMMERCIAL ALLIANCE INS CO	10906	32%	6	4	19

▶ MAPFRE

27%

83,949

110,355

308,138

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
COMMERCE INS CO	34754	26%	59,932	82,683	227,392
AMERICAN COMMERCE INS CO	19941	31%	15,177	16,347	48,901
COMMERCE W INS CO	13161	26%	5,526	7,604	20,949
MAPFRE INS CO	23876	30%	3,314	3,721	10,896

▶ NAIC 10184

25%

779

1,641

3,072

▶ NAIC 16882

25%

5,581

11,766

22,021

▶ Anchor General Insurance Company

25%

24,725

48,153

99,243

▶ Pacific Star Insurance Company

24%

2,015

4,111

8,272

▶ NAIC 24961

24%

5,898

12,826

24,876

▶ Seaview Insurance Company

22%

3,633

8,566

16,181

▶ NAIC 14012

22%

386

598

1,727

▶ Loya Casualty Insurance Company

22%

36,674

106,491

167,353

▶ NAIC 15290

21%

46,414

127,742

218,920

▶ PALISADES

20%

20,685

58,482

102,074

Member companies (largest first)

Company	NAIC	Paid rate	Closed paid	Closed unpaid	Reported
PALISADES SAFETY & INS ASSOC	22050	21%	12,028	31,588	56,984
PALISADES INS CO	10791	19%	4,207	13,091	21,983
HIGH POINT PROP & CAS INS CO	10930	18%	2,526	8,231	13,827
TEACHERS AUTO INS CO	12212	21%	997	2,757	4,698
HIGH POINT SAFETY & INS CO	10931	21%	872	2,436	4,068
RIDER INS CO	34509	11%	54	379	509
TWIN LIGHTS INS CO	12357	20%	1	0	5

▶ Lemonade Insurance Company

19%

539

1,078

2,848

▶ NAIC 16014

18%

558

1,989

3,147

▶ CLEAR SPRING PROPERTY AND CASUALTY COMPANY

16%

1,307

4,921

8,004

▶ NAIC 24821

15%

1,084

1,073

7,400

▶ NAIC 24848

13%

359

314

2,727

▶ Clear Spring Casualty Insurance Company

885

6,818

9,694

▶ Clear Spring National Insurance Company

158

1,218

1,731

▶ Clear Spring American Insurance Company

394

3,044

4,327

▶ GEICO Protection Insurance Company

116

280

1,770